Skip to main content

The Knicks' Chronic Point Guard Problems


Jose Calderon has been a no-show once again this season, and it’s difficult to say whether his struggles are due to lingering injuries or old age. His jump shot is still a reliable threat, but his inability to get separation against every point guard in the league makes him that much less of a weapon.

Calderon was never the quickest player, and he has always relied on his fundamentals to dictate the game. However, there’s a limit to how much you can compensate for a lack of athleticism with great fundamentals.

Speaking of a lack of athleticism, Calderon’s defense is non-existent. Calderon does not have enough athletic ability to run with anyone, so even if he has a great offensive game, (he is currently averaging 4.6 points and 2.4 assists) he is guaranteed to have a horrible defensive game.

I understand the significance of veteran leadership, experience, and basketball IQ, but Calderon has to come off the bench at this stage of his career. It’s a shame that this is the result of trading away Tyson Chandler, but no one said Phil Jackson was perfect. Derek Fisher needs to give the role of starting point guard to either Langston Galloway or Jerian Grant.

New York Knicks

Galloway has the edge over Grant for a couple of reasons. Galloway is a much more reliable shooter. In his first 5 games, Galloway is shooting 65% from 3-point territory. That percentage will drop, but Galloway will continue to help Melo, Porzingis and eventually Afflalo have a lot more room to run the triangle. Also, Galloway is a very underrated defender. He likes to run back on defense, and he has a great “sleight of hand” –Walt Clyde Frazier

NBA: New York Knicks at Washington Wizards

Grant has the tools to become the Knicks’ starting point guard for years to come. He’s the most athletic player on the team, he’s long for a point guard at 6’4" and he has great distributive tendencies. In fact, my criticism of Grant so far is that he is actually too unselfish. Grant is important for the second team because he is also the best on the Knicks at getting to the basket. When Melo is off the floor, a guy like Grant is very important to get other players going.


Calderon could still prove to have some relevance on this Knicks team, but a new role must be established. He could be effective coming off the bench alongside Grant as an off-ball point guard, similar to Jason Kidd in 2012-2013. Calderon is still great at shooting and passing, as long as he doesn't have to move a lot.


Point Guard is the deepest position in the NBA. Even with two promising prospects in Galloway and Grant, the Knicks are definitely one of the worst teams in the league at that position. Unfortunately, President Phil is going to have issues trading Calderon, because he still has another year on his contract, and not many people will want to trade for an overpaid, injury prone old man.

The good news is that the Knicks have legitimate depth this year, and with the cap projected to rise around $22 million next year, the Knicks will have the chance to attract another floor general in the off-season, and potentially trade away Calderon’s expiring deal.

The Knicks are not winning a championship this year, but they will be entertaining to watch. I’d like to acknowledge how nice it is that the Knicks have professional basketball players on their team.


Popular posts from this blog

Swiss Cheese D Regular Season Projections 2019-2020

Here we go, here we go, here we go! What's the point of making these rankings? The Warriors are just going to win, the NBA is rigged!

On a serious note, the Warriors look mortal! There are eight legitimate contenders this year and the NBA is great again!

Eastern Conference
Too Young, Too Unproven to take seriously
15) Charlotte Hornets

The Hornets have by far the worst roster in the NBA. Kemba leaving was devastating, but when you factor in all of the poor contracts they have piled up over the years, it makes me almost think they’re the Knicks.

14) Cleveland Cavaliers

The health of Kevin Love will determine their seeding, but even if he plays 82 games, there is not enough fire power on this team to be a legitimate playoff contender. 

13) New York Knicks

With Durant, Kyrie and Zion, the Knicks will win 10 championships in the next 8 seasons.

I have said enough about this squad. Knicks fans are going to love Julius Randle, the dude is a bulldozer. Think Zach Randolph but with bounce. The r…

Swiss Cheese D Mailbag Feat. Free Agency Potential, Dolan's Monarchy and Mitchell Robinson's Ceiling

The last month before the playoffs is usually pretty boring. The Knicks basically locked in a top 3 spot for worst record in the league, so that 14% chance at Zion seems to be what they're facing. Only time will tell if they can win the golden ticket. In the meantime, I answered some questions from my lovely Twitter followers!

Robinson is such a raw talent that it's tough to say what his ceiling is, but it is clear that he is going to get paid due to his ceiling on the defensive end. On offense, expect a high efficiency low usage player.

Similar to his mentor, DeAndre Jordan, Robinson rolls to the rim looking for lobs on basically every play. He is going to need to bulk up and set better screens, unfortunately I have seen Amar'e Stoudemire inspired screens thus far; the half-assed screens where he shies away with contact. Experience and the weight room will help with his screen setting.

The reason why he is able to be…

The Knicks are not a destination for Premier Free Agents... but hope remains

In February the Knicks took a gamble. They traded their best prospect since Patrick Ewing to offload crappy contracts in Tim Hardaway Jr. and Courtney Lee. The selling point to fans was simple: This would create two max slots to sign Kevin Durant and Kyrie Irving.

Dolan went on The Michael Kay Show stating, "Look, New York is the Mecca of basketball. We hear from people all the time, from players and representatives about who wants to come. We can’t respond because of the NBA rules, etc. But that doesn’t stop them from telling us, and they do. I can tell you, from what we’ve heard, I think we’re gonna have a very successful offseason when it comes to free agents."

July 1st provided us with a different outcome and the narrative across the media remains constant: The Knicks are a joke. We can speculate Porzingis’ health all we want. There is a legitimate argument that the Knicks dodged a bullet by trading away Porzingis before being forced to max out the tallest NBA player in NB…